Ontario province faces huge outstanding debt securities. What is Don Drummond and Moody’s saying?
Ontario Province face huge debt (has huge outstanding debt securities)
Don Drummond’s report/recommendations for Ontario released on Wednesday
Ontario’s rating outlook was cut to negative from stable by Moody’s Investors Service
Who is who?
Mr. Don Drummond
Mr. Drummond is the recently retired Senior Vice President and Chief Economist with the TD Bank. Prior to joining TD in 2000, the native of Vancouver had a long and distinguished career in the federal public service.
Moody’s Investors Service, often referred to as Moody’s, is the bond credit rating business of Moody’s Corporation, representing the company’s traditional line of business and its historical name. Moody’s Investors Service provides international financial research on bonds issued by commercial and government entities and, with Standard & Poor’s and Fitch Group, is considered one of the Big Three credit rating agencies.
Ontario has about $190 B in outstanding debt securities.
Ontario’s struggles are crucial for the country because its economy is larger than that of many countries, including Sweden, Poland and Belgium, and accounts for about 40 per cent of the national economy, with a gross domestic product of $612-billion last year.
However, the province has a $16-billion deficit and a rate of growth that is slower than that of some other provinces, which makes it difficult to find ways to balance the books.
A credit rating downgrade would not only make Ontario’s government bonds – which accounted for just over half of all trading in Canadian provincial bonds in the first nine months of 2011 – less attractive to investors, it could also make it more expensive to borrow money at the very time when the debt is mounting.
Drummond’s recommendation released
It has been about a year since Premier Dalton McGuinty asked him to dive into Ontario’s public services and find ways for the minority Liberal government to wipe out a $16-billion deficit by 2017. Mr. Drummond and his three co-authors on Wednesday served up 362 recommendations spanning more than 540 pages – the biggest print job in Queen’s Park history. He is proud of this. The executive summary is 62 pages.
“We call it the ‘summary for the not-very-busy executive.’ ” Drummond says
His proposals range from overhauling health care by moving more services away from hospitals, to scrapping electricity subsidies, to making tax breaks for businesses conditional on whether they help boost productivity, not just whether they create and maintain jobs. The general thrust through the entire document is making the success of all programs measurable, so they are run more efficiently, or junked. So far, the McGuinty Liberals have outright rejected only one recommendation – to kill all-day kindergarten.
“I hope they’ll implement them, but if they don’t, I don’t think it’s because they weren’t good ideas,” he says. “I would probably do 350 of them even if I had a huge fiscal surplus. I mean, why would you want to run a program inefficiently?” –Don Drummond says
His recommendations – hard to implement
It’s certainly nothing compared to the massive “radicalization” he is about to call for in how Canada’s most populous province operates. Mr. Drummond sounds supremely confident that his sweeping and sometimes draconian proposals offer the best hope for Ontario to get its house in order. But he is realistic about how hard it will be to implement them.
“No government in the world has ever done this before,” he says. “I’m calling for a revolutionizing, a radicalization, of virtually everything a government does, to make it focus on efficiency, not just in one area at a time, but simultaneously in virtually everything they do. It’ll take unbelievable courage and unbelievable intelligence, and it’ll take an unbelievable capacity at both the political level, and the bureaucratic level.”
Moody’s Investors Service warned on Thursday that it might lower the rating if the province doesn’t take serious steps in the next budget to deal with its multibillion-dollar deficit.
If we don’t do what he recommends, then Moody’s (Investors’ Service, the debt-rating agency) might downgrade us, increasing the cost of borrowing.” Moody’s cites Ontario’s slowing growth and growing debt for revision.